Skip to main content
25th Knesset · outgoing

Establishment of a Department for Formulating an Alternative Intelligence Concept ("Ipcha Mistabra") from the Intelligence Bodies Bill

Translated from Hebrew: הצעת חוק הקמת מחלקה לגיבוש תפיסת מודיעין חלופית ("איפכא מסתברא") מגופי המודיעין

TL;DRA proposal to establish a dedicated division in the National Security Council that will formulate alternative intelligence assessments to the assessments of the intelligence bodies.

Translated from Hebrew

What does the bill do?

The proposal establishes a new division in the National Security Council, subordinate to the head of the Council, whose role is to formulate alternative and critical intelligence assessments to the assessments of the intelligence bodies (the army, the Shin Bet, intelligence and additional units). The division's employees will receive direct access to intelligence information from government sources. These assessments will be presented to the Prime Minister and to the Ministerial Committee on Security Affairs. The head of the Council will report every six months to the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee on the division's activity.

Passed preliminary readingFirst plenum vote: November 20, 2024

The votes on this bill

Passed56 for · 36 against · 0 abstained · 28 did not vote
Source: the Knesset's vote record ↗

Coalition 68 seats

LikudFor 26 · Absent 6
ShasFor 8 · Absent 3
United Torah JudaismFor 6 · Absent 1
Otzma YehuditFor 5 · Absent 1
NoamAbsent 1

Left the coalition 8 seats

Opposition 44 seats

Yesh AtidAgainst 19 · Absent 5
Ra'amAgainst 4 · Absent 1
Hadash–Ta'alAgainst 3 · Absent 2
LaborAgainst 3 · Absent 1

Tap an MK for detailsChanged position between readingsOnly MKs who held a seat on the day of the vote are shown